At Paletería Yayo, every paleta is made the way Abuela taught us — with real fruit, simple ingredients, and the kind of love you can taste from the first bite. We're right here on Lincoln Avenue, and we've been serving up authentic Mexican flavors to the neighborhood for years.
Paletería Yayo started as a family tradition — the kind of recipe passed down through generations, where every ingredient matters and nothing gets rushed. We bring those same authentic Mexican paletas to Milwaukee's Lincoln Avenue, using only real fruit, natural flavors, and the techniques our families have perfected over decades.
Whether you're craving something classic like mango or tamarindo, or you want to try something bold like horchata with cajeta, we've got a paleta waiting for you. Every batch is made fresh in-house, and every flavor tells a story.
No artificial flavors or shortcuts — just fresh fruit and natural sweetness.
Traditional Mexican paleta recipes passed down through generations.
Every paleta is crafted the same day it's served for peak freshness.
From classic fruit paletas to creamy specialties, every one is handcrafted in small batches using traditional Mexican methods.
Classic
Sweet, tangy ripe mango blended into a smooth, refreshing paleta. Our most popular flavor — and for good reason.
Classic
A perfect balance of sweet and tart. This Mexican staple is made from real tamarind pod and is a crowd favorite.
Creamy
Creamy rice pudding meets cinnamon in this beloved Mexican classic. Smooth, comforting, and utterly delicious.
Specialty
Condensed milk swirled with rich goat's milk caramel. Decadent, indulgent, and impossible to eat just one.
Classic
Fresh strawberries folded into creamy milk for a pink, dreamy paleta that tastes like childhood summers.
Refreshing
Pure watermelon, frozen to icy perfection. The ultimate refreshment on a hot Milwaukee summer day.
And many more — our full menu changes with the seasons. Stop by and ask about today's specials!
Paletas are just the beginning. We also serve refreshing aguas frescas made to order — horchata, jamaica, limón, and more. Pair yours with a nieve (Mexican-style sorbet) for the perfect combo.
"These paletas taste exactly like the ones I had growing up in Mexico City. The horchata is incredible, and the tamarindo is perfectly tart. I drive across town just to stop here."
"My kids absolutely love this place. The staff is so friendly and the flavors are unlike anything at the grocery store. We come here every weekend now — it's become our thing."
"Best paletas in Milwaukee, hands down. The lechera con cajeta is out of this world. I also love that they use real fruit — you can really taste the difference."
1727 W Lincoln Ave
Milwaukee, WI 53215-2639
Mon – Sat: 10am – 8pm
Sunday: 12pm – 6pm
Stop by Paletería Yayo on Lincoln Avenue or give us a call. We can't wait to welcome you and share a taste of Mexico.